"I, uh. I've got this scar on my shoulder, from a wendigo bite. The way it looks, it's kind of hard to explain within the bounds of... the natural world."

Seeing as how there's not a ton of creatures your average human could get bitten by that have a perfectly circular teeth formation.

As for Peter's answer, that's... well. Not great. He'd kind of been hoping that Peter was planning to tell him at some point down the line because that is a huge thing to keep secret in perpetuity, but he guesses he still can't be super mad about it because he was pretty much planning to keep the supernatural from his dad for as long as possible until his hand was forced.

He sighs. "Okay, not gonna lie, that's not... great. What's happened before?"